‘Umrah (lesser pilgrimage) in Ramadan versus Hajj

18/10/2010| IslamWeb

Question

In Morocco, due to the large number of those who want to perform Hajj, pilgrims are chosen by lottery. Every year, more than 4,000 register in each governorate while only 98 persons are admitted. My wife and I registered for the third time and neither of us was chosen.

We are very sad and weep profusely for this. I know that in a Hadeeth the Prophet said: "‘Umrah in Ramadan equals (in reward and virtue) Hajj with me." Should my wife and I perform ‘Umrah during the great month of Ramdhaan instead of the obligatory Hajj? Or is it impermissible to give precedence to what is recommended over that which is obligatory? Please advise, may Allah reward you.

Fatwa

All perfect praise be to Allah, the Lord of the worlds. I testify that there is none worthy of worship except Allah, and that Muhammad is His Slave and Messenger.

Undoubtedly, performing ‘Umrah during Ramadan has a great virtue and abundant reward. To indicates its virtue, it is enough to mention the Hadeeth in which the Prophet said: "‘Umrah in Ramadan equals (in reward and virtue) Hajj." In another narration, he added: "…Hajj with me." [Al-Bukhari]

Nevertheless, this great virtue does not reach the virtue of the obligatory Hajj. The accepted Hajj has no less a reward than Paradise. Even if we adopted the view that ‘Umrah is obligatory, it is not sound to think that performing ‘Umrah absolves one of liability to perform the obligatory Hajj. But it is permissible to perform ‘Umrah before Hajj.

Consequently, you can seize the opportunity and go to ‘Umrah during Ramadan, or any other time, because of its great virtue and in compliance with the view that it is obligatory. Then, you should perform Hajj when you are able to. As such, you will not miss the two altogether.

However, this should be done if you most likely believe that you are financially able to perform both Hajj and ‘Umrah. If you most likely believe that you are unable to perform both Hajj and ‘Umrah, the preponderant view is that you should wait and try again and again perchance Allah facilitates Hajj for you.

And Allah knows best.